Institute of Engineering Thermophysics,Chinese Academy of Sciences;
[Objective]The energy storage policy system is relatively complex and a scientific and comprehensiveevaluation is an effective means to promote the development of the energy storage industry. [Methods]This paper usesthe entropy weight and Topsis method along with the analytic hierarchy process to conduct comprehensive evaluations ofenergy storage policies under various provinces and reflect the level of promotion of energy storage projects by policies.Firstly, considering the effectiveness of policy implementation and combined with the actual application scenarios of energystorage power plants, a comprehensive evaluation system of seven indicators covering economic, technical andenvironmental indicators has been established. Then, the representative policies from Qinghai, Zhejiang, Inner Mongolia,and Henan provinces are selecting and the results of multi-index scenario analysis based on policy content has beenevaluated with entropy weight and Topsis method. Besides, the Analytic Hierarchy Process is used to comprehensivelyevaluate energy storage policies under thinking of different focuses of multiple objectives. [Results]The results indicatethat the entropy weight and Topsis method has the optimal energy storage policy in Zhejiang Province, reflecting therelative maximization of operational efficiency of energy storage power stations under the policy support of ZhejiangProvince. Under the subjective intentions of considering economic, technical, and environmental goals separately, theenergy storage policies in Zhejiang, Henan, and Zhejiang are the most optimal which reflects the level of support fordifferent goals in the three provinces, [Conclusion] indicating the demand to establish a priority order for subjectiveevaluation of policies.
| 8 | 0 | 5 |
| Downloads | Citas | Reads |
[1]刘英军，刘亚奇，张华良，等.我国储能政策分析与建议[J].储能科学与技术，2021, 10(4):1463-1473.LIU Yingjun,LIU Yaqi,ZHANG Hualiang,et al. Analysis and suggestions on energy storage policies in China[J]. Energy Storage Science and Technology,2021,10(4):1463-1473.
[2]谢小荣，马宁嘉，刘威，等.新型电力系统中储能应用功能的综述与展望[J].中国电机工程学报，2023,43(1):158-168.XIE Xiaorong, MA Ningjia, LIU Wei, et al. Functions of energy storage in renewable energy dominated power systems:Review and Prospect[J]. Proceedings of the CSEE,2023,43(1):158-168
[3]吴皓文，王军，龚迎莉，等.储能技术发展现状及应用前景分析[J].电力学报，2021,36(5):434-443.WU Haowen,WANG Jun,GONG Yingli,et al. Analysis of the development status and application prospects of energy storage technology[J] Journal of Electric Power. 2021,36(5):434-443.
[4] BERRY F S,BERRY W D. Innovation and diffusion models in policy research[J]. Theories of the policy process, 2018, 253-297.
[5]胡竞秋，张轩，严心然，等.基于主客观赋权法的综合能源系统效益评估方法[J].广东电力, 2023, 36(1):1-8.HU Jingqiu, ZHANG Xuan, YAN Xinran, et al. Benefit evaluation method of comprehensive energy system based on subjective and objective weighting method[J]. Guangdong Electric Power, 2023, 36(1):1-8.
[6]赵晓春，吴子珺，孙群，等.双碳目标下的中国碳排放政策评价[J].统计与决策，2023,39(2):167-172.ZHAO Xiaochun,WU Zijun,SUN Qun,et al. Evaluation of China's carbon emission policies under the dual carbon target[J]. Statistics&Decision, 2023, 39(2):167-172.
[7]章穗，张梅，迟国泰.基于熵权法的科学技术评价模型及其实证研究[J].管理学报, 2010, 7(1):34-42.ZHANG Sun,ZHANG Mei,CHI Guotai. A scientific and technological evaluation model based on entropy weight method and its empirical research[J]. Chinese Journal of Management,2010, 7(1):34-42.
[8]李沛，陈晖，张博，等.“双碳”背景下煤炭转型相关政策评估研究[J].中国矿业，2023,32(7):1-9.LI Pei,CHEN Hui,ZHANG Bo,et al. Research on policy evaluation of coal transformation under the background of“Dual Carbon”[J]. China Mining Magazine,2023,32(7):1-9.
[9] OLAJIGA O K,ANI E C,OLATUNDE T M, et al. Assessing the potential of energy storage solutions for grid efficiency:a review[J]. Engineering Science&Technology Journal,2024,5(3):1112-1124
[10]李相俊，马会萌，姜倩.新能源侧储能配置技术研究综述[J].中国电力，2022,55(1):13-25.LI Xiangjun,MA Huimeng,JIANG Qian. Review of energy storage configuration technology on renewable energy side[J].Electric Power,2022,55(1):13-25.
[11]李建林，李雅欣，周喜超.电网侧储能技术研究综述[J].电力建设，2020,41(6):77-84.LI Jianlin,LI Yaxin,ZHOU Xichao. Summary of research on gridside energy storage technology[J]. Electric Power Construction,2020,41(6):77-84.
[12]赵乙潼，王慧芳，何奔腾，等.面向用户侧的电池储能配置与运行优化策略[J].电力系统自动化，2020,44(06):121-128.ZHAO Yitong,WANG Huifang,HE Benteng,et al. Optimization strategy of configuration and operation for user-side battery energy storage[J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems,2020,44(06):121-128.
[13] LIU J,ZHANG J,MA J,et al. Analysis of energy storage technology applied in grid-connected PV system[J]. Power System and Clean Energy,2011,27:62-65.
[14] CHEN P. Effects of the entropy weight on TOPSIS[J]. Expert Systems with Applications,2021,168:114186.
[15] HRUSKA R,PRUSA P,BABIC D. The use of AHP method for selection of supplier[J]. Transport,2014,29(2):195-203.
[16]青海省关于印发支持储能产业发展若干措施（试行）的通知(青发改能源[2021]26号)[M].青海省发展和改革委员会.2021.Notice of Qinghai Province on Issuing Several Measures to Support the Development of Energy Storage Industry(Trial)([2021] No. 26)[M] Qinghai Development and Reform Commission, 2021.
[17]关于浙江省加快新型储能示范应用的实施意见(浙发改能源[2021]393号)[M].浙江省发展和改革委员会. 2021.Implementation Opinions on Accelerating the Demonstration and Application of New Energy Storage in Zhejiang Province([2021] No.393)[M] Zhejiang Development and Reform Commission, 2021.
[18]内蒙古自治区人民政府办公厅关于加快推动新型储能发展的实施意见(内政办发[2021]86号)[M].内蒙古自治区人民政府公报, 2022.Implementation Opinions of the General Office of the People's Government of Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region on Accelerating the Development of New Energy Storage([2021] No.86)[M] Official Gazette of the People's Government of Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, 2022
[19]河南省人民政府办公厅关于加快新型储能发展的实施意见(豫政办[2023]25号)[M].河南省人民政府公报, 2023.Implementation Opinions of the General Office of the People's Government of Henan Province on Accelerating the Development of New Energy Storage([2023] No. 25)[M] Henan Government Gazette, 2023
[20]刘阳,滕卫军,谷青发,等.规模化多元电化学储能度电成本及其经济性分析[J].储能科学与技术, 2023, 12(1):312-318LIU Yang, TENG Weijun, GU Qingfa, et al. Scaled-up diversified electrochemical energy storage LCOE and its economic analysis[J]. Energy Storage Science and Technology,2023,12(1):312-318
[21]张翔，陈自祥，王琨，等.电网侧电化学储能经济性分析方法[J].中外能源，2023,28(3):84-89.ZHANG Xiang,CHEN Zixiang,WANG Kun,et al. Economic analysis of grid-side electrochemical energy storage[J]. SinoGlobal Energy,2023,28(3):84-89.
[24]陈志华，尤梦凯，蔡伟，等.考虑全寿命周期的储能电站综合评价模型[J].发电技术，2023,44(6):883-888.CHEN Zhihua,YOU Mengkai,CAI Wei,et al. Comprehensive evaluation model of energy storage power station with full life cycle[J]. Power Generation Technology,2023,44(6):883-888.
[23] BABU B. Self-discharge in rechargeable electrochemical energy storage devices[J]. Energy Storage Materials,2024:103261.
[24]廖东颖，朱丹蕾，谢保胜，等.参与辅助服务的电化学储能系统调峰调频技术及机制探究[J].电工技术，2022(6):127-131LIAO Dongyin,ZHU Dnlei,XIE Baosheng,et al. Research on peak shaving and frequency modulation technology and mechanism of electrochemical energy storage system participating in auxiliary services[J]. Electric Engineering,2022(6):127-131。
[25]田佩宁，梁肖，官雨捷，等.中国电网全生命周期碳排放及发电结构转型路径规划研究[J].气候变化研究进展，2024,20(1):97-106.TIAN Peining,LIANG Xiao,GUAN Yujie,et al. Whole life cycle carbon emission and power generation structure transformation pathway planning of China’s power[J]. Climate Change Research,2024,20(1):97-106.
[26]魏夕凯，谭效时，阮嘉桐，等. 2005—2021年区域和省级电网碳排放因子研究[J].气候变化研究进展，2024,20(3):337-350.WEI Xikai, TAN Xiaoshi, RUAN Jiatong, et al. Research on carbon emission factors of regional and provincial power grids from 2005 to 2021[J]. Advances in Climate Change Research,2024,20(3):337-350.
[27]江三良,陈露茜.能源产业政策与能源-环境-经济协同发展[J].产业经济评论, 2024(4):189-202.JIANG Sanliang,CHEN Luqian. Energy policies and synergetic development of energy,environment and economy[J]. Review of Industrial Economics,2024(4):189-202.
[28]缪妙，沈志宏，张良，等.浙江省工商业用户配置储能的经济性分析[J].电力安全技术，2023,25(11):16-20.MIU Miao,SHEN Zhihong,ZHANG Liang,et al. Economic analysis of energy storage configuration for industrial and commercial users in Zhejiang Province[J]. Electric Safety Technology,2023,25(11):16-20.
[29]张东辉，徐文辉，门锟，等.储能技术应用场景和发展关键问题[J].南方能源建设，2019,6(3):1-5.ZHANG Donghui,XU Wenhui,MEN Kun,et al. Application scenarios of energy storage and its key issues in development[J].Southern Energy Construction,2019,6(3):1-5.
[30]康渭滨，寇明鑫，张文文，等.光伏储能电站不同储能形式经济性对比分析[J].电力科技与环保，2024,40(03):276-285.KANG Weibin,KOU Mingxin,ZHANG Wenwen,et al. Economic comparative analysis of different energy storage forms in photovoltaic energy storage stations[J]. Electric Power Technology and Environmental Protection,2024,40,(03):276-285.
[31]刘利.中国区域能源效率与碳排放综合评估模型及相关政策研究[D].北京：中国科学院大学，2012.LIU Li. Research on the comprehensive assessment model of regional energy efficiency and carbon emissions in china and related policies[D]. Beijing:University of Chinese Academy of Sciences,2012.
[32]胡迎迎，李强，张琳娜，等.基于模糊层次分析法-TOPSIS的多元化储能典型场景适用性评估[J].电测与仪表，2024,61(6):126-132.HU Yingying,LI Qiang,ZHANG Linna,et al. Applicability evaluation of diversified energy storage typical scenarios based on fuzzy analytic hierarchy process-TOPSIS[J]. Electrical Measurement and Instrumentation,2024,61(6):126-132.
Basic Information:
DOI：10.19944/j.eptep.1674-8069.2025.02.006
China Classification Code:TK02;TM615;F426.61
Citation Information:
[1]沈昊天,张华良,徐玉杰等.基于多元目标的储能政策综合评估[J].电力科技与环保,2025,41(02):229-239.DOI:10.19944/j.eptep.1674-8069.2025.02.006.
Fund Information:
江苏省碳达峰碳中和科技创新专项重大创新载体建设项目(BM2022001); 中国科学院国际合作局对外合作重点项目资助(117GJHZ2023009MI); 南京市新型研发机构联合技术攻关项目(202304008)